Choosing the right saddle is one of the most important decisions you’ll make as a western rider. A  saddle is the connection between you and your horse – influencing comfort and performance. With so many options available, it can feel overwhelming to know where to start.

At Saddle Up Colorado, we’ve helped countless riders find a saddle that feels like it was made for them. Whether you’re preparing for long days on the trail, stepping into the barrel racing world, or simply looking for a reliable everyday option, knowing the top western saddle brands can help you zero in on the right choice. Let’s break down what to know, which brands stand out, and how to choose a saddle you’ll be happy to ride in for years.

What to Look for in a Western Saddle

A saddle isn’t a one-size-fits-all piece of tack. Here are the essentials every rider should keep in mind:

Fit for Horse and Rider

The saddle fit determines how evenly the saddle distributes the rider’s weight across the horse’s back. A poor fit can cause soreness, behavior issues, or even long-term damage. The western saddle tree is the foundation that shapes this fit, so pay close attention to it when shopping.

Durability and Comfort

A quality saddle uses high quality materials like premium leather, reinforced rigging, and sturdy fenders. Look for signs of durability, since the right saddle can last decades with proper care. Comfort also matters – not only for your horse, but for you during long rides. Features like good shock absorption and supportive seating make a world of difference.

Rider-Friendly Details

Don’t overlook the extras – a reliable saddle pad, balanced breast collar, or thoughtful design features like easier mounting can make riding more enjoyable. These details are especially important for anyone spending long hours in the saddle.

Circle Y Saddles

If you ask around at any tack shop, chances are you’ll hear Circle Y mentioned as a favorite brand. Founded in Texas in the 1960s, Circle Y has earned its place as one of the most respected saddle makers in the country.

• Known for innovation, Circle Y owns their own tree company. They strive to produce updated trees to match the current horses, making them stand out for saddle fitting.
• Their trail saddles are legendary for balance and comfort, making them a top pick for riders who spend hours outdoors.
• If you’re into competition, Circle Y also makes barrel saddles designed for speed and agility.
• They are also making strides in the rodeo world, working with PRCA and bringing in new lines such as their breakaway roping saddles.

Riders love Circle Y for combining tradition with modern technology, creating western saddles that feel great the moment you sit in them and beyond.

McCall Saddles

If you’ve ever talked with ranchers or working cowboys about tack, chances are they mentioned McCall Saddles. Built in Utah, McCall has earned its reputation as a saddle maker focused on authenticity and true-to-tradition craftsmanship.

• McCall is best known for building custom saddles that reflect the rider’s needs and the horse’s build. From horn size to seat shape, riders can fine-tune their setup for the perfect fit.
• Their saddles are designed for long days of ranch work and trail riding. They’re built to hold up under pressure without sacrificing comfort for the horse or rider.
• They are one of the few companies out there that still makes everything by hand. They produce true quality craftsmanship that is hard to find in today’s world.  

If you’re after a high quality build that feels truly yours, McCall’s craftsmanship and custom design makes it a strong contender for your next saddle.

Billy Cook Saddles

Few names carry as much weight in the western saddle brand world as Billy Cook. With decades of craftsmanship behind them, these saddles are known for authenticity and durability.

• Handmade by skilled saddle makers, every Billy Cook shows attention to detail, from hand-tooled leather to balanced rigging.
• Popular among riders in barrel racing, roping, and ranch work..

A Billy Cook is a piece of tradition, and for many riders, their favorite brand to grow with.

HR Saddlery Saddles

When it comes to custom western saddles, HR Saddlery has earned a solid reputation for precision and pride. Built with a balance of function and artistry, these saddles are made to work hard while still turning heads.

• Every HR saddle is hand-crafted with the rider’s comfort and the horse’s fit in mind, featuring quality leatherwork and a clean, timeless design. From long days on the ranch to easygoing weekend trail rides, riders trust HR Saddlery for durability without losing style, a true blend of tradition and performance.
• While HR offers a variety of saddle styles, they’ve made a real name for themselves with their mule saddles and wade trees, proving they know how to build gear that’s as versatile as the riders who use it.

An HR saddle is built with pride, and for a lot of riders, it becomes their go-to.

Other Trusted Brands at Saddle Up Colorado

Martin Saddlery

Offering premium saddles, Martin is praised for forward-thinking designs and outstanding craftsmanship. If you want a blend of tradition and performance, Martin delivers.

Cashel Company

Cashel offers dependable saddles and tack with a reputation for quality. They’re a solid choice for riders who want reliable gear at a fair price.

Scott Thomas Saddles

Scott Thomas blends modern design with classic western style. Riders appreciate their versatility and how they adapt to different disciplines.

Big Horn & Dakota Saddles

Looking for value? Both Big Horn and Dakota Saddles make it possible to get a dependable, quality saddle at a budget-friendly price. They’re also excellent if you’re shopping for a used saddle that still has plenty of life left. 

 

Big Horn specializes in large horse breeds and has developed a niche for trees that fit unique back types. 

Matching the Saddle to Your Riding Goals

Different disciplines demand different saddle designs.

 

• Trail Saddle: Prioritizes comfort and support for long hours.
• Barrel Saddles: Lightweight with a deep seat to help during quick turns. Perfect for barrel racing.
• Ranch & Roping: Built tough to handle pressure and long workdays.

 

When deciding, think about your riding style, your horse’s back, and your goals. The right saddle fit for your horse is the key to a comfortable, successful ride.

Tips for Buying the Right Saddle

• Work with saddle experts who can help check saddle fit (we’ve got you covered at Saddle Up Colorado!)
• Consider both new and used saddles – a well-maintained used option can be an affordable way to get into a high quality saddle.
• Pair with a proper saddle pad, and don’t forget supporting tack like a secure breast collar.

Find Your Perfect Fit with Saddle Up Colorado

Finding the right saddle is easier when you have knowledgeable people by your side. At Saddle Up Colorado, we carry a wide range of western saddle brands, from Circle Y and Billy Cook to McCall, Martin, and more.

Our team of riders and saddle experts can help you sort through options, whether you’re eyeing a custom saddle, comparing premium saddles, or looking for the best deal on a used one. We’re here to make sure your choice fits your horse, your body, and your riding goals. 

---